Anne Beresford
COLLECTED POEMS (1967-
(in Agenda Vols 43, no.4 & 44, no.1: summer/autumn 2008)
Subtitled:
Who Can Follow with the Eyes of Sense?
[from title of poem in Hearing Things (2002)]
Anne Beresford has been noticed in
various directories and critical journals but seldom accorded detailed critical attention
even for her outstanding recent collections: No Place for Cowards (1998) and Hearing
Things (2002). The 2006 Collected now enables us to appreciate the correlated spiritual
journey of nine major collections from 1967, as well as some notable new poems. Rather
than outline all its complex and varied aspects or assess the work in relation to
contemporary achievements, I will examine some of its intrinsic poetic methods and
qualities.
This essentially 'contemplative' poet says in the closing words of her
350 page book that she leaves 'the final sentence to the earth.' Not a sentimental
or hackneyed idea that unregenerate nature has all the answers, but signifying a
consistently 'grounded' outlook, a refusal to have recourse to the esoteric, to cool
detachment or otherworldly wishful thinking. The natural world is constantly acknowledged
in specific terms as an inevitable part of awareness; but it is never given abstruse
or fanciful motivations. As in the prose fiction of Susan Hill, natural phenomena
are intense presences that communicate wordlessly but can never be ignored. In 'Letter
from the Dead' (Landscape with Figures, 1994) the one who revisits offers no illuminations,
only an urgent plea that someone still living should relish the world's vitality
while she can.
The diverse content of the Collected surprises the reader into feeling that human
experience in all its repressed psychic corners, superstitions and its delusive hopes
and ambitions is somehow touched on. Preconceptions of logical exposition and narrative
coherence must be cast aside. The hiatus, or potent unsaid, is frequently used like
the tactical rests, without which music would be the poorer, and the result can be
a remarkable counterpointing of subjective reflection and stark, unavoidable facts.
Starting points may also take the reader off guard: the modest recurrent scenarios
of kitchen, garden, village, church often conjure up a variety of perspectives at
many levels. The whole collection also establishes a sense of unity with its internally
consistent 'world' of references, images, recurrent objects. These are subsumed and
drawn upon to give a feeling of continuity. This also applies to a wealth of tales
generated by revisiting myth and historical anecdotes: metamorphosed characters and
conflicts recur in several books, and interact on one another.
Centres of consciousness are decisive. Particularly in the earlier books the persona
whose awareness dictates the poem's development tends to be passive, moved by forces,
events, people (primarily masculine and 'monolithic' in behaviour and attitude) who
have control over material circumstances and 'externals', unaware of and insensitive
to the inner, evasive meanderings of consciousness and imagination. In later collections
this kind of narrator often feels more combative but the sense of frustration continues
to suggest the spirit's longing for freedom and expansiveness, a theme that gives
rise to many of Anne Beresford's most memorable poems. In one of several reflective
monologues set in mythical Hades (from Footsteps on Snow, 1972) Eurydice complains
of being crushed by divine edicts that ignore the individual's psyche and predicament.
'Bye Laws' from the same book expresses similar constriction in a playful satirical
glance at the omnipresent intrusion of petty rules. It begins with an invitation
to walk with a mysterious lady who embraces a unicorn and talks of her life being
embroidered in sunlight; but you cannot join her: no one may walk on the grass. Then
each less and less colourful attempt at imaginative growth is stifled by trite negation
until one must conclude: 'there are all makes of cages/even one like a chair/we can
be quite comfortable/it is forbidden/to lean out of the window'. More subtle but
still in this vein are two arresting poems from Sele of the Morning (1988). 'The
Mill Owner's Wife' purports to be a Victorian Tale. In fact the wife's austere, cheerless
account of the forbidding environment, her husband's regulated material kindness
and her longing for a softer climate suggest more than disappointed incarceration.
It is easy to be absorbed by the literal truth of Anne Beresford's direct, unadorned
tales; but in this one, as in so many, the understated implications of an asphyxiated
spirit wait patiently to be heard, like their narrator. So also in 'The Fallow Land',
a plea to someone close and loved to value and savour, and therefore share, the subtle,
nourishing details of the here and now. The restless partner is told: 'No words reach
you/no raindrops touch you/ you have taken the white road/ turned aside to the fallow
land/and it is permitted to weep/while learning to count by years not days.' Emblems
are interlaced here, but as with the 'Victorian tale', readers are given room to
find their own level of response. Arguably such poems are ultimately more sustaining
and more indicative of the entire canons's poetic strengths than experiments with
more direct autobiography set in specific circumstances, such as a series in The
Curving Shore (1975) which attempts to come to terms with social changes and threats,
formative friendships and arresting moments, all from a confused past.
However, that
early collection highlights another adjunct of the confused, ruminative narrator:
a limboid state of mind, sometimes reminiscent of The Waste Land, but without its
sardonically despondent voices. 'The Awakening' imagises the after-
Should we infer from these subjections of the passive and intuitive to a world demanding
action, enterprise and regulation that Anne Beresford adopts a 'feminist' stance,
even though her typically open and elusive manner is in itself the reverse of dogmatic?
As a deeply reflective woman writer she articulates a female sensibility, often with
attractively barbed humour, implying more than the literal surface of what's depicted,
as in this excerpt from 'Letters to Constantine' (from Sele of the Morning, 1988):
Some women
are left washing up at weddings
when the family
holding champagne glasses
pose for the festive photograph.
Dizzy, tired out
by the noise of over-
they stand at unfamiliar sinks
and dream of space craft
arriving on the lawn
filling
the garden with silent music
exotic flowers and gentle shadows.
Shadows of dreams
only
for these women also know
the outcome of weddings...
later at home they remove
their straw hats
and veil their eyes.
That last phrase has moving overtones about the need to repress opinions and insights.
But there is no suggestion here or anywhere else that the 'feminine' with all its
physical, mental and social ramifications, is the ultimate answer to a history of
male dominion and insensitivity, or that the male role should be supplanted. Once
again though, our we feel how the reflective and imaginative aspect within us all
is obliged to go to ground and veil itself. However, this poem is one of several
which focus on conflicts arising from a variety of tensions between the sexes. I
have quoted the only light-
Enclosed is the first autumn leaf
from the ornamental cherry tree
first in the garden
to redden and fall.
Night has left behind strange powers-
disturbed, something inside
me is crying.
Sun shines on the yellow daisies
pears drop from the old tree
and the
wind is gentle.
Whose shadow on my door?
Who spoke my name?
The sequence in its entirety is reminiscent of Tennyson's Mariana poems with their
power, as the critic Lyall commented, to suggest 'the correspondence and interaction
between the mind and its surroundings, between the situation and the subjective feelings.'
'Relict' (from Landscape with Figures, 1994) goes further by conveying the empty
domestic routine of a woman drained of purpose and abandoned by a male partner. A
well-
More dramatic but still anchored in palpable
emotional and physical conditions is
And when your friends
brush past me in the kitchen
impatient, sneering,
I relive
the time when, far off in Germany,
your work, your genius undisturbed
by messages
of grief,
I rested my head/against the empty cradle.
Even more forthright and uncompromising is 'The Mothers' (from Hearing Things, 2002)
At one level it is an ironically authoritative appraisal in quasi-
This detached, layered technique points to another
decisive facet of Anne Bereford's poetic approach to a wide diversity of human experience.
Her spare narrative exposition punctuated by pregnant silences and hiatuses makes
for a universal, scaled-
Come morning he stands
with dew on his feet
by a grave dug as carefully
as his asparagus
bed./
"Bury me here alongside
my carrots and strawberries.
I am your man."
And similar to this quiet hint at the futility of judicial murder is another legend-
It was the child who broke the spell
crept out one morning
to search for primroses
forgot the grey shapes
half hidden by the trees.
One of us saw him
running breathless
down the avenue
towards the downs
a last speck of white.
Why? cried his mother
banging
her head against stones
why?she wept
into her hands...
Equivalent work in the later collections is more matter-
Complementary poems in the same book carry further this mythical imagising of dimly
grasped forces, forgotten or sanitised in a world absorbed with one-
'Rootedness' is a constant
feature of what might be called poems that are concerned more specifically with a
spiritual journey, though it is to some extent a misleading subdivision, since every
poem in the Collected is part of a lifelong tentative enquiry into what makes us
human and how we live poised between various needs and appetites. Which is no doubt
why an attractive hallmark of the more 'metaphysical' poems is their comprehensiveness,
a refusal to allow artificial and misleading divisions between the material and spiritual,
the symbol and the symbolised, 'real' and 'unreal'. The earliest collections are
apt to be preoccupied by memories, often fragmented and confused, that hint at wider,
indefinable realities; but in The Curving Shore (1975) a sense of 'pilgrimage' begins.
The soul's life is a haphazard journey requiring full engagement with the world as
it is, but towards a gradually emerging goal. Accompanying it, but taking all kinds
of elusive and unpredictable forms, there is a presence who tests, guides, reassures,
as in the 'The Comforter': 'Days drop with the leaves/are trodden into the earth-
But the point is more arrestingly conveyed in 'Leiston Abbey' from Songs a Thracian
Taught Me (1980), indicating that Anne Beresford's most disturbing and memorable
poems surprise us out of easy, blinkered contentment with surfaces. Two people visit
ruins in a meditative, prayerful mood, and notice a rabbit carved in stone. Aesthetically
pleasing, it adds to the sense of peace and stillness, its folded paws merging with
greenery; and then: 'The stone moves gently/as though a heart were beating quickly./
And bending down I see that the stone/is alive and suffering./This is its sanctuary./
Nothing makes sense/ with the heavy clouds spitting rain/onto the rabbit, its eyes
obliterated/by the large swellings of diseased flesh.' Such insistence on inclusive
reality is found in another context in the same book. 'Elusive Love Poem' addresses
the 'Master of Disguises' as 'near' in a dirty train full of ill-
Anne Beresford's more directly theological poems, though often intended to relate
to contiguous, contrasting pieces, are sometimes less convincing than those which
dramatise an indirect apprehension of the numinous in unlikely places. Yet some of
these reflections have the sinewy compactness of R.S.Thomas's verse: direct but leaving
a sense of unplumbed mystery; peculiarly abstract and specific all at once. Two poems
from Landscape with Figures (1994) stand out in this respect. 'Omens' digests with
an undertow of wit the Old Testament history of Yahweh the tormentor, a theology
which results in subtle spiritual paralysis: ' but Yahweh's head is balder/his breathing
slower, heavier/his rage is calculating/ For the first time prophets raise their
heads/anxious/silent.' So, too, in 'The Surprise' the divine manipulator is caricatured:
'And God said:/Let them be pushed/through a corridor/into the light/ready/to be pushed/through
a corridor/into the dark/.../Hope shall be their despair.' Two gnomic poems in Hearing
Things (2002) are just as laconic but far-
Two poems from No Place for Cowards (1998) with a narrator confiding in the individual
soul, are a variation on this idea. 'Crossing Over' combines quietly intractable
images of the physical world with a strange angle on near-
How had it come to this
how could he have imagined
when manoeuvring seas
heavy or
placid-
his natural habitat-
that he would land up here?....
His body becomes unfamiliar
dry, colder, he can feel it wither
his eyes
dimmed
survey a lost world
and he swallows
its beauty
as he would a shoal of fish.
Perhaps the revisiting of biblical tales and episodes is an adjunct of all these
explorations. Poems of this kind, whether early or late, are well-
where she'd been dragged,
now stood there
wondering what the man-
with dirty feet-
was writing in the sandy soil,
wondering if death was nearer than she'd thought.
And then silence.
The two of them suddenly alone
sun very hot for the time of day.
To return to 'pilgrimage', there are two revealing poems at the beginning of No Place for Cowards (1998): 'February for the Crazy Pilgrim' and 'The Crazy Pilgrim in Conversation'. These assert the mutual vibrancy of body and spirit, distil Anne Beresford's attitudes to deceptively acceptable divisions between levels of experience, suggest what her work has amounted to and where it must lead.
'I'll not creep through each day
head bowed, feet tentative/
Away with amulets
sprigs
of mistletoe
white heather
there's no place for superstition....
It is remarkable
to conceive a desire for a new life
when the present one is only slightly worn
but
I am fearful of losing myself
losing the world would be no loss
but imagine losing
oneself
imagine looking in the mirror
and not being there.
There is no quick fix and we must face up to contradictions. The term 'crazy' has
significance similar to that in W.B. Yeats' Words for Music Perhaps (1932), a series
of lyrics uttered by Crazy Jane, crazy in the sense of being finely cracked through
the wear and tear of experience, as well as dementedly frank. Part of one of her
dialogues with the bishop is most indicative: 'Love has pitched his tent in/The place
of excrement./ For nothing can be sole or whole/That has not been rent.' There's
no room for over-
Perhaps the most outstanding of these are informed
by an acute but never despondent sense of mortality. To mention just few (three of
which envisage male protagonists) indicates their range of subject matter and technique.
The tale of a faux pas by 'George Eliot's Piano Tuner' is told in a brisk form that
feels as tight-
...he walked in late autumn
under the trees in brown afternoons
thought of the soft
skin on her neck
where her necklace lay.
Those words never spoken.
A last adagio
orchestrated in his brain
not meant for human ears,
celebrated by trees
the copper
of beech
knotty trunks of oak
vibrating in wild winds
blown from nowhere.
'Death on the NHS' employs dry, restrained humour to rein in felt but unspoken frustration.
The health machine feels like a faceless juggernaut with its own detached programme,
as suggested in this densely packed metaphor: 'The end was a shattered lamp/paramedics
trampling broken glass/and kindness underfoot.' Officialdom displaces feeling: 'You
can't see the dead without an appointment/and with one you must wait/but not here/half
in, half out of a busy ward/with telephones ringing/nurses scurrying and raised voices.'
As in the Collected's best meditative writing we are disturbed but allowed room to
supply our own details. In 'The Sale of Mr Buzby's House' we encounter just one example
of this poet's talent for expressing bereavement in its many aspects. Here one is
moved not just by the breaking of long attachment to various items, but by the way
this is reported in a sympathetic yet matter-
Did I tell you about the piano?
Once, he played me a nocturne,
D Flat major, he told
me.
I listened as the sun dipped into night
and I wept a little
at the closing bars.
His fingers were so delicate.
Such a gentle threnody, and yet the style works quietly below the surface with the
metaphor of diminishing light and the final metonymy for the fragile gift of life.
The informing spirit of this whole collection is openness and heartfelt response
to what happens, whether or not it is palatable or 'convenient.' 'Angels' (Hearing
Things, 2002) is indicative. They are not shining presences but unlikely bearers
of unexpected blessings to which you may or may not respond. ('Only afterwards a
smile or a word/suddenly becomes illuminated.') Similarly the contiguous 'List for
the Gardener'. He never comes, his physical appearance can't be recalled or predicted,
and the list of disorder grows, perhaps another emblem for patiently awaiting the
clear path of illumination. But the conclusion is especially apt: 'We'll make a new
list to leave on the kitchen table/Then someone will find it and say:/Is this the
beginning of a new poem?' Poetry like angels consists of apparently off-